Race to the Bottom – Part III
Friday, October 2nd, 2009The Bank of England continues to do its best to debase Sterling by printing as much money as possible without scaring the gilts market. The only reason Sterling hasn’t collapsed against other currencies is that the other major central banks are all involved in various forms of printing money (quantitative easing) themselves. Sterling is however steadily weakening against the Euro as the ECB is the only major central bank not currently printing money freely (see Vee are Not Embarking on QE).
But the BoE has shown it means business by recently increasing the amount of money it is planning to print from £125 bln to £175 bln and the Governor letting it be known that there is more money where this came from as he would rather print £200 bln. The Governor is doing his best to stay ahead of the likely £175bln-plus of gilts to be issued this year. However so far the QE money spent by the BoE has ended up mostly in commercial bank reserve deposits back at the Bank of England (a telling indication of just how much cash the banks now have is that 3-month Sterling Libor at 47bps is now below the Bank Rate for the first time since the credit crisis broke in the summer of 2007). The challenge is how to get this money injected into the real economy given that households and corporates don’t want to borrow and companies are preferring to launch rights issues to fund their acquisitions with equity rather than debt (and the REITs are busy selling new shares to pay down their debts too).
The BoE have hinted that the next trick they will try in their attempt to move the money currently held by the banks at the BoE is to stop paying interest on this money. Given that the Bank Rate is only 50bps then reducing it to zero may not be a big enough incentive and the banks may well just shift the money into the very short end of the gilt market. However not paying interest on commercial bank reserves will come in very handy when the time eventually comes for the BoE to start raising interest rates again, so we can expect this policy move to happen at some stage. The more drastic step of paying a negative interest rate on commercial bank reserves (by charging the banks interest to deposit money at the BoE) will achieve nothing as the logical response from the banks would be the same – shift the money into short-term gilts.
With everyone looking to raise equity and retire debt, getting the QE money into the real economy may take a quite a while longer to work (there is no history to refer back to here as the Japanese were too timid when they tried QE). In the meantime the BoE has little option other than to carry on printing money until a sustainable economic recovery takes hold. Expect Sterling to continue to depreciate against real assets and harder currencies such as the Euro.