Over the past few weeks the Euro has formed a triple bottom at 1.3450 against the Dollar (the lows were on 19 Feb, 25 Feb and 2 Mar 2010).  Triple bottoms are rare in markets because most times a market prints a bottom, bounces off that bottom the first time it is tested but breaks through the support level if it is tested again (hence the old trading adage “Fade the first test but Go With the second test”).

The Euro now appears to have absorbed the selling pressure which has resulted from the problems Greece has been having in refinancing its borrowings.  Whilst the EU has pledged not to abandon Greece it has still not given any firm details on how it plans to offer support to Greece other than to encourage Greece to reduce its budget deficit towards 3% of GDP (as per the euro-zone’s Growth & Stability Pact).  Greece for its part “would like to borrow on the same terms” as other euro-zone members.  However the bond markets will demand a substantial premium to lend money to Greece until it proves it is actually carrying out the deficit-reduction measures it has promised in recent weeks. Yesterday Greece sold a €5 bln 10-year bond with a coupon of 6.25%, yielding roughly 312 bps over Bunds.

It has also become clearer over recent weeks that any support extended to Greece by the EU will not formally involve the ECB printing any money.  Euro-zone member governments have met public opposition to bailing out Greece with taxpayers’ money and the German press in particular has run stories opposing bailing out Greece if it means Greek public sector workers can still retire earlier than their German equivalents or even suggesting Greece sell off some of its uninhabited islands to raise some money.  Greece has in turn demanded the Germans return Greek gold which the Nazis allegedly stole during World War II…

Back to reality.  The receding prospect of the ECB printing money has helped the Euro to find support over recent weeks.  There is a subtle difference between the ECB printing money in order to buy Greek bonds and other euro-zone banks buying Greek bonds yielding circa 6% (with a strong nudge and guarantees from their respective governments) which they then use as collateral to borrow money from the ECB (at 1%).  The latter is simply good banking even if the net effect either way is the ECB finances loaning Greece money.  In the latter case the ECB can correctly claim that the risk lies not with it but with the banks.

Now that the Euro has found support at 1.3450 (until the market proves us wrong), the forex market can switch its attention to giving the Pound Sterling a good kicking in the run up to the May General Election.

The Dow made it as far as 9,918 in the rally after the FOMC statement was released on Wednesday 23 Sep 09 before turning around and selling off for the rest of the week.  Does it matter that this rally off the March lows hasn’t made it all the way to the magic round number of 10,000?

The bears keep pointing out that the market is on too high a p/e ratio for a new bull market to be truly underway and therefore a big correction must be just around the corner.  However see “Is the Bear Market Over?” for the reasons as to why the Dow is unlikely to take out the 6 March 6,470 low.

The bull’s case can be summed up in a beguilingly simple way:  The Fed and the BoE are determined to keep interest rates close to zero and carry on printing money until a sustainable economic recovery is underway.  As it is the stockmarket’s job to discount the future then it doesn’t matter what the shape of the economic recovery is going to be (V, W, U or the more exotic Square Root sign), it is more important that an economic recovery is on its way and therefore the market will keep on rallying in order to discount the coming recovery and will continue to frustrate those people who are looking for a big pullback so that they can buy into the market.

The problem the bears have is that anyone disagreeing with the bullish argument above is essentially saying that the central banks are going to fail in their mission to reflate the economy and help an economic recovery to take hold.  There is a very old saying in the markets which goes “Don’t Fight the Fed”.

The central banks have more money than individual stock market participants and thus far the Fed has promised to print $1.75 trillion (they are slowing down the rate of spending as the economy appears to be entering a gentle recovery but rest assured, they will print more money if the economy stumbles again in 2010).  The BoE is set to print £175 billion and they are not slowing down the printing presses as the Governor would prefer to print £200 billion and then see how the economy is getting along.

Possible events which could derail the current rally include a sharp sell-off in the Government bond markets, the monoline insurers being downgraded, problems emerging in German banks once the 27 Sep elections are safely out of the way, Spanish banks admitting they are in trouble with their loans to property buyers and developers (how are the Spanish workers going to generate enough money to service their mortgages when nearly 20% of them are unemployed?) or the US economy slipping back into recession next year now that the boost to demand created by their “Cash for Clunkers” program has expired and especially if the Bush tax cuts are reversed at the end of 2010.  However for now these potential problems are hiding over the horizon and, with interest rates close to zero, the stockmarkets may continue to frustrate the bears and just carry on squeezing higher, climbing the “Wall of Worry”.  We have already had the “Dash for Trash” and therefore the next part of the rally will have to be led by the big quality blue chips.

The head of the ECB Jean-Claude Trichet was most insistent during his press conference after the latest ECB meeting that their proposed purchases of €60 bln of “covered bonds” (mostly mortgage-backed securities issued mainly by German banks) did not mean that the ECB was commencing quantitative easing.  His exact words during the Q&A session of the press conference were “we are not at all embarking on Quantitative Easing”. 

Instead the €60 bln covered bond purchase plan was presented as providing “enhanced credit support” to the covered bond market which will help to improve the spreads, depth & liquidity of this particular market, seen by the ECB to be in particular trouble at the moment.

The Bundesbank has clearly dug its heels in over the ECB going down the road of QE and has compromised by agreeing to throw €60 bln instead at the covered bond market.  Good to see the old City adage “If there is a problem then throw money at it until it goes away” has been taken on board by the burghers of Frankfurt.

Meanwhile the Bank of England has taken that particular City adage to heart by expanding its QE program from £75 bln to £125 bln.  And if that does not do the trick then expect the BoE to throw even more money at the problem…there is no shortage of money to spend when the BoE can just print it (even if they describe this printing as “electronically crediting the accounts of those instituitions” which sell securities to the Asset Purchase Facility).  The BoE is aiming to ease the flow of credit throughout the economy by purchasing gilts (mostly).  It hopes the selling institutions will re-invest the proceeds elsewhere, thereby boosting asset prices & tightening credit spreads.  It also hopes that some of this money will leak out into the wider economy and end up as spending on goods & services.  By restricting their buying to gilts, the BoE will be unlikely to lose money as they are financing their purchases at near-zero rates of interest and will likely hold the gilts to maturity.  By spending a big percentage of the Government’s borrowing requirement, the BoE is also hoping its purchases will help to avoid private borrowers being “crowded out” by the deluge of gilts being issued.  Expect the BoE to spend much, much more than £125 bln before its Quantitative Easing program comes to an end.  They truly are going to throw a great deal of money at this problem until it goes away.