Last Thursday the Fed raised its discount rate by 25 bps to 0.75%, as highlighted 8 days previously in Bernanke’s Exit Strategy speech on 10 Feb 2010.  As a result it now stands 50 bps above the upper limit of the current 0% – 0.25% range for the Fed Funds rate.  The Fed also took the opportunity to announce the return to the usual 1-day time limit for banks borrowing at the discount window (down from 30 days which was first put in place on 17 August 2007 - as the credit crunch first started to bite).  These actions indicate that the Fed is confident that the banks have now got their funding arrangements back into good order.

Despite the FT’s Lex column (20 Feb 2010) claiming that the discount rate is “almost irrelevant these days”, the Fed’s discount rate will become very important when the Fed eventually begins its next rate tightening cycle.  This is because the discount rate effectively represents the upper bound of the overnight interest rate during the period when the Fed is steadily raising rates.  The market doesn’t care about the lower boundary for overnight interest rates when rates are trending higher.

The Fed has also taken the precaution of giving itself the option of paying interest on money that US banks have placed on deposit at the 12 Federal Reserve Banks ($1.1 trillion is currently sitting on deposit).  In this way the Fed can force market interest rates higher should it prove difficult to get the Fed Funds rate moving in the desired direction (because of the $1.725 trillion which the Fed has thus far supplied to the markets via its Quantitative Easing efforts).

However any actual rise in US interest rates is still over the horizon and well out of sight.  The Fed has a so-called dual mandate to both contain inflation and promote employment (unlike the ECB which is only tasked with keeping inflation under control).  US unemployment is still very high at 9.7%  and, counter-intuitively, the unemployment rate may well rise further as a strengthening economy creates jobs.  Bernanke said in testimony this week that low interest rates “are supporting a nascent economic recovery”  and that “although the federal funds rate is likely to remain exceptionally low for an extended period, as the expansion matures, the Federal Reserve will at some point need to begin to tighten monetary conditions to prevent the development of inflationary pressures”.  In plain English, the Fed is going to wait and let the economy grow and create lots of jobs before risking its first rate rise. 

The Fed is simply getting its ducks in a row by preparing the ground for an eventual rate raising cycle.  It has to raise the discount rate first in order to create some additional headroom above the Fed Funds rate which it can then rise into.  By raising the discount rate well in advance of any hike in the Fed Funds rate, the Fed can now sit back and watch the market’s reaction, paying particular attention to 3-month Dollar Libor (the rate at which banks borrow Dollars from each other for a period of 3 months), which has been trading around 26 bps for many weeks now.

The Fed would like banks to borrow from each other and ideally to obtain funds from depositors rather than directly from the Fed itself at the discount window.  Historically the discount rate has been kept 100 bps above the Fed Funds rate and we can expect the Fed to aim for this level in future months.

The first hint of higher interest rates in the States arrived after this week’s FOMC meeting.  Thomas Hoenig (President of the Kansas City Fed) emerged as the first interest rate hawk on the FOMC and voted against an unchanged monetary policy.  Hoenig “believed that economic and financial conditions had changed sufficiently that the expectation of exceptionally low levels of the Fed funds rate for an extended period was no longer warranted”.  In plain English Hoenig wants the Fed to signal to the markets that it is going to begin hiking interest rates at some stage in the not too distant future.

At the moment Hoenig is the only dissenter on the FOMC.  It will pay to keep a close eye on whether his view gathers support at future FOMC meetings.

The market’s reaction thus far to Wednesday’s announcement has been most evident in the US Dollar.  Its rally, which began after the 4 Dec 2009 Employment Report, has continued and the Dollar Index (DX) has now broken above its 200-dma.  The 50- and 200-week moving averages are the next resistance levels to be surmounted and they lie just above the current 79.59 level of the DX.  Hoenig hankering after US rate hikes will only serve to help the Dollar to extend its recent rally.  Commodities (as measured by the CRB index) have reacted badly, the US stockmarkets have remained under pressure (but they started falling two weeks ago) but the all-important US Treasury bond market has traded sideways despite Hoenig hinting at higher rates sooner rather than later.

However it is difficult to believe that the Fed is going to implement the first rate hike until the US economic recovery has gained significant traction which results in a very visible fall in the unemployment rate from its current 10%.  There is so much spare capacity in the States that the Fed can afford to let growth continue to build momentum without worrying about higher inflation resulting anytime soon.  Any premature rate hikes would be a serious policy error which would impact the economy & stockmarkets severely.

A more likely explanation for Hoenig’s action in voting against the others is that it allows the Fed to test the market’s reaction to a proposed change in the current policy stance of “low rates for yonks”.  If markets react badly over the next few weeks (particularly if the US bond market tanks) then we can expect all the other FOMC members to very publicly bang the drum that interest rates are not going up anytime soon.  The FOMC knows full well that it will eventually have to tell the markets that rates are not going to stay at “exceptionally low levels for an extended period” and this is a low risk way for it to prepare the markets for an eventual change in monetary policy.

I still think that the first US rate rise is out of view and over the horizon (and more likely to take place in 2011 than 2010) but will be paying close attention to future FOMC statements for clues as to when policy is likely to change.